You’ve probably heard of the black market, an illegal marketplace where prohibited goods are sold, such as weapons or smuggled electronics like mobile phones, which are among the most commonly traded items.
To help you better understand the black market, here’s a full explanation:
What Is the Black Market?
The black market refers to an underground marketplace where illegal transactions take place, outside the laws of the Republic of Indonesia. The goods sold in the black market often originate from hidden or untraceable sources because they involve items that violate social norms or legal standards.
These typically include illegal drugs, weapons, stolen goods, and smuggled items such as mobile phones, firearms, and even cigarettes—often sold to avoid taxes or licensing requirements.
Factors Behind the Black Market
Several unavoidable factors contribute to the emergence of black markets. Some of the main ones are:
1. Government Restrictions
When a government bans the sale of certain goods (e.g., weapons, drugs, or restricted chemicals), some people may resort to selling them illegally through black markets.
2. Lack of Official Documentation
Stolen goods are difficult to resell in the legal market due to the absence of official documentation. As a result, perpetrators choose to sell them on the black market.
3. Tax or Duty Evasion
Some products, like cigarettes, are subject to excise taxes. To avoid paying these fees, sellers may distribute such goods through black market channels.
4. Banned or Restricted Goods
Goods that are either restricted or banned, like pornography or content related to race, religion, and ethnicity, often end up on the black market.
Sources of Black Market Goods
Black market goods often originate from smuggling, which refers to illegally acquiring items that are restricted or banned by law.
In conclusion, most of the goods sold in black markets are smuggled and sold freely without government oversight.
Pricing in the Black Market
Prices on the black market vary. Some items may be cheaper than in legal markets because sellers do not pay taxes or regulatory fees. On the other hand, some goods are more expensive because they are rare or legally restricted, making them hard to find in official markets.
Despite the cheaper prices, many consumers still prefer to buy from official sellers for the following reasons:
-
Buyers distrust black market sellers, seeing them as dishonest.
-
Official sellers offer easier communication, more payment options, and better customer service.
-
Purchasing stolen goods can lead to criminal charges.
Still, black markets continue to grow because some consumers seek cheaper prices or items that are banned in legal markets. The biggest loser from these growing illegal transactions is the government, which loses out on customs and tax revenue.
Examples of Black Market Activities
1. Data Theft
Black market trade isn’t limited to physical goods. In May 2020, Indonesia was shocked by a massive data breach where a marketplace was hacked and user data was sold illegally.
The stolen data included private user information, bank account details, and social media credentials—illegally sold on the black market.
2. Drug Trafficking
As widely known, drug distribution is strictly prohibited in Indonesia. However, dealers and addicts often operate through the black market.
According to a 2017 survey by Indonesia’s National Narcotics Agency (BNN), at least 3.5 million Indonesians were using illegal drugs. These individuals use the black market as a platform for distribution and access.
3. Illegal Fishing
During the tenure of former Minister of Maritime Affairs and Fisheries, Susi Pudjiastuti, illegal fishing was widely reported—often involving boat sinkings as part of enforcement.
Even more alarming, illegal fishing often goes hand-in-hand with drug and weapons smuggling. Minister Susi once stated that such operations are managed by large syndicates operating within the black market.
Given Indonesia’s vast maritime territory, illegal fishing poses a serious threat. If left unchecked, it can destroy marine ecosystems and disadvantage local fishermen.
4. Human Trafficking and Prostitution
Since 1852, Indonesia has struggled with commercialized sex work, especially when it was allowed under Dutch colonial rule. Sadly, even after independence, this issue continues.
Prostitution is deeply concerning as it often involves minors and veers into human trafficking.
